|
Post by Narninian on Apr 28, 2004 1:54:48 GMT -5
it seems I forgot to put Kalena there - she would go in my NOT SURE category because she hasnt posted much since she was brought it as a replacement.
|
|
|
Post by AuntieSocial on Apr 28, 2004 7:20:04 GMT -5
Doesnt anybody want to talk?!? So its my belief that pie_is_good, jewel, and BSR are mafia. I've already explained my beliefs for my vote on PIG - I hope others see what I see. Here’s my thoughts … such as they are … Probably Innocentnonbeliever - I agree that nonny is most likely an innocent, although most of my gut feeling there is based on the people who were gunning for her ... one of whom has now been confirmed as an innocent ... did Hilly see something in her behaviour that justified him voting (so ardently) for nonny? He did say (towards the end of his life) that he found her defense to be reasonable, but still didn't remove his vote. Not Sure[/u] Kalena/dingleberry - I'd also have to put Kalena in the "Not Sure" category, due to the lack of posting (which she has justified). Narninian – you arrived on Day 2, which means you weren’t part of the hit on Kalena, but that doesn’t exclude you from being involved in the hit on Yaw. You did vote for Hilly, but I can’t fault you on that one, I admit that I, too, found Hilly suspicious and was one of those who participated in his death ... but all of us (at one time of another had found Hilly suspicious) ... so I'd have to factor you into the "Not Sure" category. BaalShemRa - BSR seemed suspicious to me on the first day, with his unorthodox manner of playing, but this is his first game of mafia. Somewhere between Not Sure and A Little Suspiciouspieisgood - I'm still unsure of pie. On my list, he floats between "Not Sure" and "A Little Suspicious" Pretty much everything that pie has done that may be suspicious to me, I saw Yaw doing … the only main difference between the two of them was the no-lynch thing on Day 1. Both sides of that issue seemed logical to me, and I just don’t know if that’s enough for me to lynch pie. Probably MafiaJewel - I am (and have been from the beginning) suspicious of Jewel. Unfortunately, she seems to have gone inactive, so we have nothing new to go on (since about mid-afternoon yesterday, though that doesn’t mean she didn’t participate in the night kill). The only one I feel strongly enough about lynching is Jewel, (and again, this is based mainly on my gut feeling and her voting behaviour over the last two days). I just wonder if we will get a defense from her *shrugs* Vote: Jewel
|
|
|
Post by AuntieSocial on Apr 28, 2004 7:30:53 GMT -5
That being said, we are in a VERY difficult situation here ...
At least two of our townspeople (Kalena/nonny) are busy with exams, as is our moderator. Another townsperson has her house up for sale and wants desperately out of town (Jewel).
And we have to get it right today. I'm going to think out loud for a moment and go through each of the scenarios ...
We have 7 residents now, 3 are scum, 4 are innocent, no doctor (no nurse)
Scenario 1 - We lynch a scumbag: That leaves 6 residents as follows: 4 innocents 2 scum A night kill would leave 3 innocents and 2 scum with a lynch requirement of 3 tomorrow (another chance)
Scenario 2 - We lynch an innocent: That leaves 6 residents as follows: 3 innocents 3 scum A night kill would leave 2 innocents and 3 scum with a lynch requirement of 3 tomorrow (impossible - game over, mafia scumbags win)
Scenario 3 - No-lynch That leaves 7 residents as follows: 4 innocents 3 scum A night kill would leave 3 innocents and 3 scum. I'm not sure how the lynch requirements are determined with equal numbers ... if it's 3, we have one final chance, 4 would be impossible
|
|
|
Post by BaalShemRa on Apr 28, 2004 10:49:51 GMT -5
Well, I'm busy with finals too, yet I'm posting.
If Jewel isn't there, 4 votes are going to be impossible to get ( unless some mafia vote too, which, if the person accused is guilty, is impossible and if the person accused is innocent, we shouldn't be voting for ). In other words, if Jewel won't be posting and we have a reqiurement of 4, we are at the mercy of the mafia.
|
|
|
Post by Narninian on Apr 28, 2004 11:25:00 GMT -5
UNVOTE: Pie_IS_GOOD
That is unless Jewel IS mafia. we HAVE to lynch scum today, tommorow, and the next day to win. To lynch scum we need to get all the townies to agree on a targret or the mafia has to vote for scum to appear innocent.
I believe Jewel is mafia so its safe to VOTE: Jewel
It was truly my belief that 2 or 3 out of the 4 people who were on Nonbeliever's bandwagon - are scum. Since hilly turned out to be innocent - that leaves BSR, Pie_is_Good and Jewel - which turn out to be my top suspects.
|
|
|
Post by nonny on Apr 28, 2004 18:08:22 GMT -5
ok I believe someone asked what is up between me and Jewel, correct? Well I have no idea she has just been gunning for me since day one. So I know i'm innocnent and I guessing she is scum because all the pieces fit.
VOTE:JEWEL, can we get a vote count ck or Yaw?
[ot]Um I don't have exams till june, I'm moving into a new house(tomarrow) I am only able to post once a day till friday.[/]
|
|
|
Post by BaalShemRa on Apr 28, 2004 18:16:40 GMT -5
Narm and Non have convinced me. Non must be innocent and Jewel has been single-mindedly after her.
Vote:Jewel
|
|
|
Post by Yaw on Apr 28, 2004 22:54:11 GMT -5
I've informed ck, but he was having problems getting the board to come up. Be patient. I'm sure he'll be here soon to finalize the lynch.
|
|
|
Post by Narninian on Apr 30, 2004 10:51:18 GMT -5
*MOD-PROD uhh.h... MOD*
we NEED to know!
|
|
|
Post by AuntieSocial on Apr 30, 2004 19:01:10 GMT -5
*MOD-PROD uhh.h... MOD* we NEED to know! Mod-Prod, eh? That almost sounds, well, painful ... I guess we just need to wait it out?
|
|
|
Post by Yaw on May 1, 2004 22:59:27 GMT -5
Well, folks, I just ran into ck in chat. Turns out this forum no longer works for him. (I'm sure he'd appreciate technical support, if anyone can offer it.) Looks like I'm taking over.
With 4 votes, Jewel is lynched. You throw her off Ye Olde Cliffe. A search of her house afterwards reveals nothing of interest. Looks like she was just a townie.
(Death scene posted because Jewel wanted replacement and doesn't seem to be watching this thread.)
With 6 left, 3 of them scum, that's a win for the mafia. Congratulations, guys. You can now reveal yourselves.
Get ready for Mafia 4, run by pieisgood. Given his posting in here, I'm looking forward to a great game. Sign up in the queue if you're interested, and ONLY IF you are going to put in the time. We want to try to avoid the replacement merry-go-round this time, thank you.
|
|
|
Post by AuntieSocial on May 1, 2004 23:09:30 GMT -5
With 6 left, 3 of them scum, that's a win for the mafia. Congratulations, guys. You can now reveal yourselves. Steps out of the shadows and smiles while swinging her piano wire garrote casually ... (mafia)
|
|
|
Post by BaalShemRa on May 1, 2004 23:50:25 GMT -5
It's over. Mamma mia!
|
|
|
Post by Yaw on May 2, 2004 0:01:38 GMT -5
Oh, I knew it was you and pieisgood, BaalShemRa. Too bad AuntieSocial snuffed my pieisgood-wagon. I had no idea she was scum. Complete surprise.
For those interested, my protection targets were: Night 1: AuntieSocial (oops) Night 2: Narninian
Good game, people!
|
|
|
Post by AuntieSocial on May 2, 2004 0:05:21 GMT -5
Thanks for the protection, Yaw! *giggles*
I was getting worried with all the attention pie was getting ... how to sway attention away from him without implicating myself ... I decided 'playing daft' was the best course of action ... "Ummm, I stil don't understand how a no-lynch could be such a bad thing ..." etc
|
|